How supermarkets flog EXACTLY the ‘same’ food for twice the price

How supermarkets flog EXACTLY the 'same' food for twice the price

SUPERMARKETS are selling near-identical products at different prices – and charging more than double for a nicer-looking label.
Morrisons, Asda, Tesco and Sainsbury’s all sell own-brand products that have the same ingredients and weight as items in their value ranges – but some cost twice as much.
Tesco sells two 340g packs of honey – a glass jar that costs 99p in its value Stockwell & Co range and one in a squeezy plastic bottle that costs £1.80
The Sun analysed products at Britain’s four biggest supermarkets and found that all sold slightly different versions of the same product at different prices.
Some products weigh the same and have the same ingredients, but the value range can be half the price.
The biggest price difference we found was at Tesco.
The supermarket charges 48p for a 200g Stockwell and Co branded pack of roasted and salted peanuts, but £1 for a near-identical packet under its Tesco own-brand label.
Sainsbury’s has two versions of own-brand low fat natural yoghurt which are both 500g and contain the same ingredients but the basics product is 15p cheaper
Both of these 1 litre cartons contain 100 per cent apple juice from concentrate but you’ll pay 27p more for more exciting packaging
All four supermarkets are selling different versions of the ‘same’ products at vastly different prices
Both packs weigh 200g and they have the exact same ingredients.
In some cases, value range products are made to different recipes, which is why the price can be cheaper.
In all our examples, the packaging is different, which may also account for the price discrepancies.

Some supermarkets may also argue that its own-brand label items are better quality than its basics range products.
But in many examples we found, products have exactly the same ingredients and weights yet still have different prices.
Both of these 500g packs of spaghetti just contain dry pasta – but there’s a 25p price difference between them at Asda
These cans of chopped tomatoes from Asda have the same ingredients and weigh the same but have a price difference of 7p
Sainsbury’s charges 15p more for its 75p 1.5kg own-brand plain flour than for its 60p basics plain flour.
Both are made with 100 per cent fortified British wheat flour.
Meanwhile, Tesco charges £1.80 for its own-brand 340g Squeezy Clear Honey but only 99p for its 340g Stockwell and Co Honey – despite both containing 100 per cent pure honey.
In another example, Asda charges 25p more for its 45p own-brand 500g spaghetti than for its Smart Price 20p 500g spaghetti.
These tins of sweetcorn in water from Morrisons have a 35p price difference despite weighing the same and containing the same ingredients
Tesco charges more than double for a 200g bag of roasted and salted peanuts under its own-brand label than for its Stockwell and Co brand even though the bags weigh the same and contain the same ingredients
Morrisons sells its 1 litre Savers apple juice from concentrate for just 55p, but its 1 litre own-brand apple juice from concentrate for £1 – a difference of 45p.
Morrisons confirmed to The Sun that shoppers pay more for the packaging, because the more expensive item has a “resealable plastic tab,” whereas the savers product does not.
A Sainsbury’s spokesman said: “Our Basics and Sainsbury’s ranges are designed to offer customers a variety of products at a range of prices.
“The price for different products are influenced by a range of factors.”
An Asda spokesman said: “We offer a wide range of products at price points to meet all of our customers’ needs.
“While these two products contain the same overall ingredients, the gradings do differ.”
The Sun has also contacted Tesco for comment and we will update this story if we hear back.
It’s not the first time this issue has come to light.
Last year, Channel 4’s Supershoppers exposed other examples of supermarkets selling near-identical products at vastly different prices.
RecipeEASE-TER TIME Spend Easter relaxing with family thanks to Mrs Crunch’s hassle-free recipes EGG-STRA SPECIAL Amazing Easter eggs where the shells are filled with chocolate bars TOY JOY Mothercare launches toy sale with up to 70% off PLUS 3 for 2 EGGS-ELLENT VALUE We rate the Easter eggs that get you the MOST chocolate for your money MCLOVIN’ IT McDonald’s Monopoly starts NOW – and you could win up to £100,000 HOW SWEET How you can bag a HUGE £10 box of Cadbury chocolates for FREE
Meanwhile, nearly 60,000 Asda workers could lose their paid lunch breaks under new contracts.
If you want to get some fizz in for Easter, head down to Aldi as it’s slashed the cost of bubbly to £4 a bottle.
If you’re after something a little different for Easter, Lidl is selling a sweet wine that tastes like hot cross buns.
Secrets Of Your Supermarket Shop reveals some bagged salad may contain deadly bacteria

We pay for your stories! Do you have a story for The Sun Online Money team? Email us at


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here